Nobunaga Was Not Always Ruthless

While Oda Nobunaga is often portrayed as a ruthless conqueror in game and anime, he sometimes showed his compassions for people.

The following account is from Ohta Gyuichi [1], a retainer of Nobunaga. His book is considered relatively reliable.


Fig. Oda Nobunaga (wood sculpture)

Photo courtesy of Gifu Castle

This is a replica of a 16th-century wood sculpture. Among the many depictions of Nobunaga, this one aligns with descriptions I’ve read, featuring his small mouth, well-defined nose, wrinkles between the eyebrows, and a nervous disposition.

Fig. Yamanaka

This is a schematic picture. The interested reader can visit the Wikipedia site at

http://shmz1975.cocolog-nifty.com/blog/2014/08/post-9b49.html


In the late 1570’s CE, Nobunaga often commuted from Mino to Kyoto. Along the way, there was a place called Yamanaka, where a physically disabled man was always begging by the roadside. Nobunaga, seeing this man on commuting, he asked the townspeople why this man was begging always at the same place, because a beggar usually doesn’t have a fixed place to live. They replied,

 “Long ago, this man’s ancestor killed Tokiwa Gozen [2] in Yamanaka. As retribution, the descendants of the killer are born with disabilities and live as beggars. This is he who the towners callthe monkey of Yamanaka’.”

He was physically disabled such that he couldn’t go anywhere else. On June 26th, 1575 CE, Nobunaga had to urgently travel to Kyoto. Remembering this man, he had his retainers prepare 20 tans [3] of cotton. It should be noted that cotton in those days was a precious good mainly imported from abroad. [4]

Passing through Yamanaka, he saw this man as usual. Nobunaga issued a proclamation:

“All people, both men and women, must appear. There is something to be announced.”

The people, fearful of what might be said, reluctantly gathered. Nobunaga entrusted the townspeople with the 20 tans of cotton, saying,

“Use half of this cotton to cover the costs of building a hut nearby for this man, and ensure he does not starve.”

Nobunaga said to the villagers,

“It would be appreciated if the nearby villagers could give him some wheat when there is harvest, and some rice after the autumn harvest. Twice a year, in small amounts as long as it would not be a burden on their part.”

Not only the disabled man but also the people wept. Nobunaga’s retainers also shed tears and made some donations.

It is unclear whether Nobunaga’s actions had any political connotation. The author Ohta’s description feels too real to have been fabricated.

If Nobunaga resided in Kyoto instead of commuting, the Honnoji incident [5] could not have happened and he might have completed his goal: unification of Japan.

[1] Ohta, G., Shincho Koki (modern translation by Nakata, T.), Shin Jinbutsu Bunko, Tokyo, 2015, tenth printing.

Ota Gyūichi (1527-1613) was a retainer of Oda Nobunaga, and his extensive materials and detailed explanations make his book a relatively reliable source. English translation:

 "Chronicles of Lord Nobunaga", 

 https://brill.com/display/title/19759
[2] Tokiwa Gozen was the mother of Minamoto Yoshitsune (1159-1189), younger brother of Minamoto Yoritomo, the first Shogun.

[3] 1 tan is 10-12m long width being 37-38cm. The measure tan is still used in 2024 for kimono clothing.

[4] In mid-16th century Japan, cotton was highly valued for making cloths. It was especially important for samurai garments, because cotton was good in absorbing sweat. It was also good for daily undergarments and summer clothing. Cotton was also used to produce futons (bedding) and other household textiles. Because of its rarity and cost, cotton items were often reserved for the wealthy and were considered luxury goods. Additionally, cotton was sometimes used in religious and ceremonial contexts, where its quality and purity were appreciated. 20 tans of cotton in the 16th century could be highly valuable because as Nobunaga says, half of it suffices to build a hut

[5] In 1582, when Nobunaga was staying at Honnoji temple, Kyoto with only 150 soldiers, his own general Akichi Mitsuhide revolted with 13000 soldiers. Nobunaga committed seppuku.



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Japan: A Late Bloomer

Movie Review: “Visas and Virtue” (1997), A 26-minute Short Film Directed By Chris Tashima.

Movie Review: "Lil Tokyo Reporter (2012)" A Short Film Directed By Jeffrey Gee Chin.